Showing posts with label triangulation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label triangulation. Show all posts

April 17, 2014

Thursday Hillary Bash - Bill Tacks Right?

Out - triangulation.  In - New Improved Triangulation with more Bill in Billary.

Hillary Clinton has a problem.  The left doesn't think she's liberal or progressive enough.  Having had a taste of full on progressivism in president Obama, the far left is not likely to want to let it go.  In their eyes Obama did not go far enough, and a Hillary Clinton presidency in 2016 would actually represent a step back towards the center in their view.  The left would rather select an Elizabeth Warren type as their nominee.  So Hillary needs their votes.  But Hillary's problem does not end there.

Hillary has a problem with the right and possibly the center as well. As Karl Rove pointed out on Fox News this morning, She beats out Christie, Jeb Bush and Rand Paul by roughly 50 - 41 each in a poll conducted on the presidential election recently.  Rove suggested that the 50% represents a ceiling for Hillary since she can't seem to surpass it no matter who the opponent is, and in each case, those opponents still have a number of unknowns about them. Hillary on the other hand is a known commodity.  She's at her support ceiling right now.  There's no guarantee she can remain there.

What to do? Bill Clinton perfected triangulation but everyone is onto that trick, so the Clintons may have come up with a newer approach to winning voters that borrows from president Obama's be everything to everyone when campaigning.  It's the 2-for-1 package approach.  The notion is that when you get Hillary, you also get Bill.  They'll argue that when you had Bill, you also had Hillary too.  It's a partnership.

From a campaign perspective, it allows Bill to tack right to pick up voters while Hillary can continue to pander to the left.  Bill can drag voters over from the right and the center. It pushes that potential ceiling upwards from 50% to a more winnable ceiling level.  The Clintons together, can be everything to everyone.

As evidence, Bill Clinton has taken a stand against voter ID laws.
AUSTIN, TEXAS (NNPA) – Former President Bill Clinton praised President Lyndon B. Johnson for signing the 1964 Civil Rights Act and the 1965 Voting Rights Act into law, but said the progress that stemmed from those landmark measures are being undermined by Republican-led efforts to suppress the vote.

“We’re here because the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act made it possible for Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton and Barack Obama to be president of the United States,” Clinton said to loud applause during a speech last Wednesday that was part of a 3-day celebration of the 50th anniversary of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

Clinton said 10 states require some form of state-issued ID before allowing voters to cast a ballot. Last year, the U.S. Justice Department sued Texas and North Carolina over their voter ID laws, charging that undercut voter participation by Blacks and Latinos.

...Supporters of the ID laws say they are needed to curb voter fraud. But the Justice Department and civil rights groups said voter fraud is minimal.

...Calling Johnson a “son of the South,” Clinton described him as “a Texan bred with the state’s outsized ambitions (who) saw limitless possibilities in the lives of other people like him, who just happened to have a different color skin.” He said, “Just as Abraham Lincoln stewarded the 13th Amendment through Congress, Johnson’s leadership embodies the power of the presidency to redeem the promise of America,” Clinton said in his speech here.

But that promise took a beating last year when the U.S. Supreme Court invalidated Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, the provision that requires states with a history of discrimination to pre-clear any voting-related changes with the Justice Department or a federal court in Washington, D.C. before implementing them.

Clinton criticized the ruling that was decided by the court’s conservative majority.

“Any time you erect a barrier to political participation [by people] … based on their race or their physical capacity or their income … it undermines the spirit of the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act,” he said.
Voter ID laws are something a lot of conservatives bristle at because of privacy, especially in light of the NSA scandals of the last year.  Bill's argument about it setting back the civil rights efforts provides cover to Hillary to argue to the left that he means it with respect to civil rights progress.  He's framed his argument that way. But Bill meanwhile can peel off some youthful libertarian support from the GOP that might otherwise support a Rand Paul worldview by tacking to the right in his argument when faced with a different audience.  It won't change the opinions of those concerned with the issue of voter fraud - a predominantly Democrat driven problem - but it doesn't need to do so. It just needs to attract those who are concerned about an overly intrusive government.  A lot of Tea Party supporters can identify with that notion.

The Clintons don't really want to be everything to everyone.  They just want to do enough to win another election.  From that perspective, this new approach to electioneering is brilliant and it isn't yet being countered by the GOP who may not even recognize that the 2-for-1 approach will present a formidable challenge to any GOP nominee.

May 22, 2009

How to change the mind of a liberal

Do you ever get the feeling that President Obama has got this hyper-triangulation thing going on? He's shifting the country drastically leftward, yet talking to middle class as if he were a centrist. He's taking over banks and car companies but saying he doesn't want to be in those businesses. He's after cap and trade or something similar and CAFE standards but claiming to be on the side of American business and wanting GM to recover. He's beholden to the UAW but cap and trade and CAFE will prevent the automakers from recovering properly. He was against military tribunals for Gitmo detainees before he was for them. He talks fiscal sanity but is fiscally insane. Listening to him speak, who would know where he stands on abortion?

The list goes on and on. He's all over the map, but with a steady drift leftwards. Why is that? He wants the leftward drift and he's getting it. So is he some sort of political mad genius? An idiot-savant? Or is he just flailing around from problem to problem without real solutions and grasping for whatever life preservers are handy?

I think the answer is both. He doesn't know what he's doing as far as running the country goes, but he's politically astute enough to try to take every opportunity and turn it into a shift leftward. It's not so much hyper-triangulation as Dick Morris suggests, but rather hyper Rahm-Emmanuel-ism; never letting any issue, crisis or otherwise, go to waste.

The problem with that is that ideology ends up governing every solution and common sense gets elbowed out of the equation and the results will just get weirder and weirder. If you think Government Motors is surprising, by 2012 it might be the tamest thing to come out of the Obama administration. The beauty of conservatism is that common sense is the basis of every solution.

Revisiting what Rush said - 'I hope he fails', I do too. It is separate and distinct from I hope the country fails. I hope he fails to foist his neo-socialist policies on the country. Maybe enough Democrats will show some spine on health care to prevent it from happening, maybe not. But the real measure of his failure or success will not be determined by President Obama in the next four years.

Ultimately Obama will fail to execute his radical agenda. Enough conservative grassroots momentum will trigger changes in 2010. That momentum will carry through to 2012 and Obama will be a one term President. Then, any radical thing he's implemented will have the chance to be reversed. Any damage he does during his tenure need not be permanent if conservatives and enough moderates realize the implications of how he's jeopardizing the nation's future and act.

How can I be so sure he will fail? Honestly I can't. But the evidence, while painfully slowly, is beginning to mount that people are getting nervous about his agenda. His popularity will inevitably decline.

HOW TO CHANGE THE MIND OF A LIBERAL

But you can ensure that Obama's damage is contained. You have to become involved. You can't wait for the GOP or conservative pundits to do this for you - there's no time. Not everyone can attend a Tea Party, but if you can do so. More importantly, if every conservative were to convert a non conservative voter, we'd own the electoral map. Of course that's easier said than done, so I've included a recipe for you to follow. Don't worry, there's no Kool Aid involved.

1) Find a moderate or non-radical Democrat friend.

2) Determine what issue matters most to them.

3) School yourself on that issue and the details of both the liberal and conservative position.

4) Discuss, in a friendly, non-confrontational but convincing manner the advantages of the conservative position and the disadvantages of the liberal position.

5) Be prepared to back up your points with facts and ready to require them to cite their sources. You aren't looking to humiliate them though just enlighten them. If they can't cite a source, ask them why they believe it. If they can, ask them to question the source by checking out some other sources.

6) Be patient. The acceptance does not come overnight in most cases.

Remember unlike the left that wants to badger and ridicule people into agreement, we want them to come willingly and enlightened into the fold. You are here to persuade them that they can come to a clearer world view. You want them to come to you for more detail, or with questions. When that happens, you have opened a door for them to walk through.

I know that seems like a lot of effort, but the country's future is worth it. And compared to the effort of radical liberals/progressives/socialists/Alinsky-ites it's nothing. You don't need to paint your face, wear a pink wig - unless you really, really want to do that. You don't need to shout silly pre-programmed slogans or assault anyone. DON'T.

Once you've completed that effort, come back and share your comments here on your successes and failures. This can be a learning experience for all of us on how to best change the mind of a liberal. I'd also like to keep 'score' on the success rate of people who try it.

March 5, 2009

Inside the Carville phone call on Rush



The Democrat attack on Rush Limbaugh, according to Politico, was a contrived plot.




Top Democrats believe they have struck political gold by depicting Rush Limbaugh as the new face of the Republican Party, a full-scale effort first hatched by some of the most familiar names in politics and now being guided in part from inside the White House.


The strategy took shape after Democratic strategists Stanley Greenberg and James Carville included Limbaugh’s name in an October poll and learned their longtime tormentor was deeply unpopular with many Americans, especially younger voters. Then the conservative talk-radio host emerged as an unapologetic critic of Barack Obama shortly before his inauguration, when even many Republicans were showering him with praise.


Soon it clicked: Democrats realized they could roll out a new GOP bogeyman for the post-Bush era by turning to an old one in Limbaugh, a polarizing figure since he rose to prominence in the 1990s.


Democrats are all over this - not just those mentioned above, but Rahm Emanuel, Americans United for Change, David Plouffe, the Democratic National Committee, and Media Matters are all involved according to the Politico article. And they can't contain their glee - with Bush gone, they've got their new villain.


But the Democrats have got this wrong, and judging by the initial knee-jerk reaction of Michael Steele, so do some Republicans. Attacking Rush will provide the Democrats some short term gain but long term pain. This is the very danger that Rush spoke about years ago talking about governing by polls. In this case it's politicking by polls.


Governing means leading not following the direction of the wind. Even President Obama apparently understood this concept when he said something to the effect, referring to the economy, that you can't lose sight of the long term by following the fluctuations of the daily market . Rush pointed out the directionless drift a government can take on by leading by polls. They should instead lead and allow the polls to follow their success or failure. Triangulation, being all things to all people) has seemingly been perfected by President Obama. And in an election, apparently it can be used very effectively. But when you apply it demonizing an opponent based on a poll you risk long term problems to achieve short term success.


What have the Democrats gained by demonizing Rush Limbaugh? It was a tactical win because it provides a great distraction from the economic meltdown that continues unabated. But how long can it remain a distraction? If they keep at it people will wonder why the Democrats aren't focused on the pressing issue of economic collapse. The alternative is to let it die down and then its really only bought them a few days.


Moreover Rush isn't the demon the far left see in him. Its been easy to make him a bogeyman when people who have never heard him think he's a lunatic. He scores badly in younger demographics. Guess what, 90% of those people who have a negative impression of him have probably never before heard him speak a word. But now he has exposure. Now he can communicate with them at least fleetingly and has a chance to allow them to develop an honest opinion rather than a soundbite impression. Rush knows this. He can serve two purposes here in the same effort - grow his audience and expound conservatism's virtue and benefits. He has to be careful how he does it but there is huge conservative upside here.


This was a classic over-reach. They thought they were on such a roll they could tar and feather Rush whom they despise while tying him to the GOP direction. Perhaps they thought it might sew a longer-term discord in the conservative ranks - the Rush camp vs. the Steele camp is an extension of conservatives versus moderates in the fermenting GOP debate. That too will abate. While there may be some in-fighting short term it will subside. It has to - the party will coalesce around a new contender by 2012 because it has to do so. The alternative is 4 more frightening years of Obama.



Unless of course the Democrats keep poking the wound with a stick and keeping the carnage fresh but appearing to take their eyes off the real problems. Or perhaps they think they can balance both.


But here's where this becomes a strategic level blunder. Rush won't lose any listeners by continuing and he may in fact gain gain some. He knows that. So he will continue to invite the President to a debate. He will exercise his broadcast muscle and stir the pot himself. It's in his own best interest to do so. And with the added exposure it gives him the microphone for a relatively uncontested 3 hours a day with new listeners listening in. Any percentage that listens more than cursorily will realize he is not a lunatic, but rather that while passionate, he makes reasonable, reasoned arguments. Against Democrats. How much impact that has is debatable. But it certainly is worth more than 2-4 news cycles of distraction.



If the Democrats ploy adds 10% more listeners to Rush that's an extra 2 million people. If 50% of them end up staying on board, that's 1 million and of those, at least 75% will be swayed to conservatism. Rush IS that good. That means a 750,000 voter switch from 2008. And that's on top of whatever happens to the Obama popularity ratings during the same time. And four years is a long time. That number could grow even more.



What looks like bad news for the Republicans and great news for the Democrats, I predict, will get turned on it's ear. Whether Rush is the de facto leader of the Republican party is irrelevant. What he can do for them by taking advantage of this opportunity is very relevant. Good luck Rush.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Share This